Friday, July 20, 2007

SNAPE IS LOYAL...(PART II)

OK, I know that the last post was long but defending Snape is not something that can be done with only a few words. Plus, I know some of you will have questions about other things that may seem to spell out a different outcome entirely, such as...what about the prophecy? Alright, that is a big hurdle. Or is it? In Half-Blood Prince Harry confronts Dumbledore about the meaning of the prophecy. "...neither one can live while the other survives..." Harry assumes that one of them, either he or Voldemort, will have to kill the other, to which Dumbledore agrees. The prophecy also says that "the one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord will be born as the seventh month dies". Both Harry and sweet Neville Longbottom were born in July, on the same day! So why isn't Neville the one having to defend himself at every turn? As Dumbledore says, it is because Voldemort, having heard only a small portion of the prophecy, made his CHOICE and marked (with a scar?) Harry as his equal thus making Harry Voldemort's nemesis. The intruiging thing about this prophecy is in its vagueness it helps to re-illustrate the idea of CHOICE as a factor in Harry's life. Voldemort chose Harry as his opponent, not Neville. So my question is, what difference does any bit of the prophecy really make? Everything that has happened to Harry, beginning with the murders of his parents, is a direct consequence of Voldemort's choice to go after him. We must suffer and accept the consequences of our actions. That is what I believe to be the important lesson gleaned from the prophecy. Their meaning is only defined by what actions we take as a result of our interpretation of them. And since Snape never actually mentions Harry's or the Potters' names in reference to the prophecy, I hereby remove all guilt and blame from Snape for the Potter deaths!!!

Another interesting question that I read in a published thesis on Snape is what would his Bogart and Patronus look like? The authors of the thesis said that Snape's worst fear, as seen in his Levicorpus depantsing at the wand tip of James, is exposure. Physical, in this case (emotional exposure also exists as a fear for Severus but how could this be embodied in a corporeal being?). Perhaps an image of him upside down with greying underpants visible? Maybe. I however, have more fun imagining what form his Patronus would take. Seems obvious doesn't it? The only happy thing in his life was Lily. How touching would it be to see Severus use his Patronus as a shield charm and see Lily's glowing, angelic form emerge to protect him!

I also can't let any discussion of Snape go with out expressing my absolute adoration of Alan Rickman!!! Casting him was a stroke of pure genius (as has been the case for all the cast members). He is a symphony of sarcasm and scene stealing one-liners! I loved him as Hans Gruber in Die Hard, I fell in love with him in Truly, Madly, Deeply, and I am in awe of him as Snape! He stole Order of the Phoenix and god forbid I am right about my prediction, when 2010 rolls around and we get the movie version of Deathly Hallows, his death scene will be unbearable!!!

OK. Thanks for listening to my rambling!!! Post comments and ideas please!!


LONG LIVE SEVERUS SNAPE!!!!

1 comment:

Gretel said...

You are the only person I know that would put this much time and effort into this. I just finished the book, and am eager to talk to someone about it.