48hrs 61min 33sec and counting until the end of the greatest literary saga I can ever imagine reading!! I am both excited, like a 7 year old on Christmas morning, and anxious to find out if my prediction for the end of the Harry Potter series (more to the point who's end) is accurate. If I am right, and by popular opinion it seems as if I am, I will be extremely sad and heartbroken. Not just because this is the end of the series (what the hell do I do 2 years from now when I would normally be expecting another book?), but because I firmly believe that one of the two major characters who will meet their end in The Deathly Hallows will be Severus Snape. I mean, come on, book 6, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince is all about him! And, THE pivotal chapter, Spinner's End, is told more from Snape's point of view than anyone else's. JK Rowling is setting him up for redemption! Since HP and the Philoshopher's Stone I have felt that Snape was very misunderstood and that there was much more to him that would undoubtably endear him to us in the end. It is here in this post that I will make my case for Snape as the trustworthy anti-hero he has become.
However, before I go on about Snape's innocence, let's get some other things, that will obviously have a major impact on the events in Deathly Hallows, out of the way. First, R.A.B. has to be Regulus Arcturus Black, Sirius' former Death Eater, now dead younger brother. The story goes that he quickly lost his stomach for the Death Eater life and was killed, either by Voldemort or someone else (that bitch Bellatrix is an obvious suspect), when he tried to get out of it. Curiously though he seems to have been successful in partially thwarting Voldemort's plans to continually split his soul into various meaningful objects thereby creating a Horcrux and granting himself eternal life. If we are right in assuming that R.A.B. is Regulus Black, Regulus, in the time before his murder, was able to obtain and summarily destroy Salazar Slytherin's locket (or was he?), which Dumbledore believed to be one of the 6 Horcruxes. Considering the nature of the object and its significance to Voldemort, I would imagine that to destroy it one would have to have some measure of strength, magically speaking of course. Sirius never had much good to say about Regulus. In fact, he thought he was pretty much a witless git, so we never (at least so far) get a full view of Regulus' abilities. I will be anxious to hear how/if he destroyed it and how that might have contributed to his death. Also, when Dumbledore and Harry journey to the cave in Half-Blood Prince to destroy what Dumbledore thinks is the locket, the potion that Dumbledore drinks recalls the pleadings of a man for mercy for one of Voldemort's victims. My question is, who do these pleas for mercy belong to?
Second, the Horcruxes.....I think most Harry Potter scholars are in agreement about this list so here it is: 1. Tom Riddle's diary, destroyed by Harry in The Chamber of Secrets. 2. Salazar Slytherin's ring, destroyed to devastating personal effect by Dumbledore in Half-Blood Prince. 3. Slytherin's locket, worn by Merope, Tom Riddle's (aka Voldemort) mother. We at least know that the locket was removed from its original hiding place in the cave and replaced by another. The question remains, at least in my mind anyway, was Slytherin's original locket actually destroyed by Regulus Black or was he killed beforehand? Wasn't Kreacher, the Black family house elf, in possession of a locket in Order of the Phoenix? 4. Helga Hufflepuff's goblet, current whereabouts unknown, but known to have been stolen by a young Tom Riddle whilst working at Borgin and Burkes, that Knockturn Alley antique shop. 5. Something of Rowena Ravenclaw's, suggestions welcome! I haven't figured this one out yet. Knowing JK Rowling it has to be something we have heard of before but I can't put my head around this one. 6. Something of Godric Gryffindor's, again, have no idea. Some say it could be Gryffindor's sword that Harry used to kill the basilisk in Chamber of Secrets. That is the best possibility I have heard but I wonder how Tom/Voldemort could have gotten a hold of it, created the Horcrux, and returned it to the shelf in Dumbledore's office? The seventh piece of Voldemort's soul, whatever is left of it after all of his murderous rampaging, still lies within him, according Dumbledore. If the other six bits are destroyed, perhaps the part that is left will be easier to vanquish.
OK, now for the good part! This part of my prediction I am particularly proud of. We all know what a brilliant author JK Rowling is and how clever she is at hiding clues within her story lines. I set out to reread books 1-6 and make careful note of things I thought were vital to proving Snape's innocence. In doing so, I focused on the two premiere themes of the series, CHOICE and LOVE. The power of LOVE is first introduced to us in The Philosopher's Stone when Dumbledore (R.I.P. Richard Harris) tells Harry that the reason Professor Quirrell could not kill him was because of the love his mother had for him and her life-sacrifice she made to save him. This presentation of LOVE as a protective form of magic is an obvious one. Most recently, in the film version of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, in the scene where Voldemort temporarily possesses Harry, Harry uses the power of the LOVE he has gained, felt, and given in his friendships with Ron and Hermione to overpower Voldemort. He even tells Voldemort that that is how he will defeat him because Voldemort has never known love or friendship. (This was, to me, the most touching scene in a rather disappointing movie. I'll not go into that though! That's for a whole other post!) The more subtle presentation of LOVE as a theme, and one in which a character's final portrait will be defined, is as it pertains to Severus Snape. Snape is the teacher we all love to hate. But something keeps most of us from really loathing him. There is something sympathetic, even pitiful about him. This is finally proven in The Order of the Phoenix chapter entitled Snape's Worst Memory. Harry rather rudely invades a memory that Snape has left swirling in the pensieve. To his horror, Harry witnesses his father's and Sirius' mean streak as they publicly humiliate and torture Snape when they were all 15 years old. Snape is stripped literally and figuratively in front of the entire school. James levitates Severus and depantses him (other articles that I have read have theorized the greying state of young Snape's underwear as a symbol of his sad upbringing and isolated nature) and is left as a helpless target of everyone's ridicule.....until Lily Evans arrives!!! Lily immediately responds to James' actions with anger and orders him and Sirius to leave Snape alone. Lily is the only one to ever, and in public, stand up for him! She berates James for his unprovoked act of cruelty. However, Snape responds by calling Lily a mudblood and saying he doesn't need her help. Now if anyone saw this response as anything other than that of a lonely, frightened, angry 15 year old I'd have to say you weren't ever a teenager! This is a classic "Fright or Flight" response. Severus can accept Lily's help and forever suffer taunts in excess of what is already dealt him on a daily basis by the Marauders, or retreat safely to his lonely interior. At least there he knows what to expect. Can you imagine the sadness he feels trapped in the persona of an outcast, with no friends, no childhood happiness, and like the child Tom Riddle, a penchant for the Dark Arts? And imagine the impact of Lily's concerned defense of Severus on his self-esteem! It is likely earlier than this that Severus develops a crush on Lily. Professor Slughorn says in Half-Blood Prince that it is no wonder that Harry is stellar at potions because his mother was "the most gifted potions student I ever knew". Next to Severus Snape of course! Perhaps, Severus and Lily harboured a friendship, at least within the confines of Potions class. Also, we can't ignore the brief glimpses Harry has of a much younger Snape, cowering in a corner at home while his father is verbally abusing Snape's mother. Snape's protective isolation began at home! Lily may have been the only one to ever outwardly show concern or care for him and he never forgets it, even if he has to hide himself from it.
Now the image of Snape as a sad, lonely child should be familiar! Remember Harry's experience when he joins Dumbledore in revisiting his early memory of Tom Riddle at the orphanage? How was Tom depicted as a child? Sad, lonely, gift for dark magic.....The parrallels between Severus and Tom I think are vital to the theme of CHOICE, which I will illustrate later. Meanwhile, Snape grows up and we can assume his disillusionment becomes bitterness when Lily eventualy falls in love with and marries James Potter, his childhood nemesis. I bet Snape felt betrayed, even though he never expressed his feelings towards Lily to anyone. Logically he turns to the only other safe haven he knows, the Dark Arts. Just so happens a band of fellow Dark Arts afficionados is forming with a very charismatic leader at the head! Voldemort and his fellow Death Eaters welcome Severus into the fold and Severus is glad to feel a part of something for once. He is good at it and is rewarded! He is also at an early stage very impressionable because of his self-imposed isolation as a kid. No one in their right mind would ever trust Snape again based on his devoted membership into the Death Eater clan. There has not been, up until the climactic murder of Dumbledore in Half-Blood Prince, any one viscious act attributed to Snape. However, he has been presumed guilty by association until Dumbledore vouches for him at the Ministry hearings following Voldemort's downfall. Dumbledore continually and unwaveringly professes his trust in Snape. Why? Fast forward to Half-Blood Prince when Harry learns that it was Snape (!) who overheard the prophecy and reported back to Voldemort.....
"Professor Snape made a terrible mistake. He was still in Lord Voldemort's employ on the
night he heard the first half of Professor Trelawney's prophecy. Naturally, he hastened
to tell his master what he had heard, for it concerned his master most deeply. But he
did not know - he had no possible way of knowing - which boy Voldemort would hunt
from then onward, or that the parents he would destroy in his murderous quest were
people that Professor Snape knew, that they were your mother and father.....You have
no idea of the remorse Professor Snape felt when he realized how Lord Voldemort had
interpreted the prophecy , Harry. I believe it to be the greatest regret of his life and
the reason that he returned..." (Dumbledore to Harry in Half-Blood Prince, pg 549)
Later in the cave with Harry, Dumbledore hears the frantic pleas for mercy of someone begging for the life of someone else at the hands of Voldemort. I believe that voice to belong to Snape, pleading for Lily's life. Once he realized that she and James were targets he instantly felt the magnitude of his own actions and feared the consequences. It is because of his deep long love, admiration, and respect for Lily that he risks his own skin to try and protect hers. But who could stand a chance against Voldemort once he has made his decision? Devastated, Snape secretly vows revenge and "at great personal risk" he turns spy for Dumbledore and the Order. Dumbledore is privy to Snape's feelings for Lily and knows that Snape's remorse is genuine. Snape's confession proves his heart is true. Snape has made a CHOICE out of LOVE for another. This is where CHOICE becomes a vital theme as well. In The Chamber of Secrets Harry asks Dumbledore why the Sorting Hat did not place him in Slytherin House. After some thought and goading by Dumbledore, Harry realizes that while he does possess the skills Slytherin valued, he was ultimately sorted into Gryffindor because he chose to! While it's not until Half-Blood Prince that we realize the similarity between young Tom Riddle and young Severus Snape, throughout the years we have witnessed the effects of CHOICE on both men. Snape could have very well have become another Lord Voldemort had he not chosen to act out of love. The seeds of evil were already there. He was neglected by his father, ostrasized at school, brilliant at the Dark Arts, poor, not particularly attractive, teased, ridiculed, humiliated, and loved a girl who did not love him in the same way back but "betrayed" him and married his rival. Tom Riddle was the son of a muggle father who abandoned his pregnant wife, his mother was not there for him (death in childbirth), scared his fellow orphans with the Dark Arts, and who never loved or was loved by anyone. They are both half-bloods. Both with muggle fathers and witch mothers. Not one thing about their lives is any different except the choices they each made. Dumbledore himself says to Harry in Chamber of Secrets that is is the choices we make that define us. I believe, with a very heavy heart, that Snape will be remembered as one of the most honourable of men, but will not achieve his redemption until he defeats Voldemort himself. In his final loyal act of LOVE, for Lily's sake and Harry's, I think he will sacrifice himself.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
of course, only you would have researched this and wrote a report. but i agree. snape will be vindicated.
it is so hard for me to believe that dumbledore is really dead and that he wouldn't have known about black's brother getting the locket, though.
i just read book 6 and saw phoenix movie. i also reread the last part of phoenix.
i am so excited!!!! i ordered the book from amazon and it better get here on sat. i am tempted to just go buy it from barnes and nobles sat. morning.
i am going to be so depressed when this is over.
You and I both!! I am expecting to be very depressed late Saturday (no way I'm putting this book down once I get my hands on it). I won't know what to do, either if I'm right about Snape and he dies or about the fact that the series will be over!! I guess that speaks volumes about how much joy I have taken from these books! It's hard to imagine ever loving another book as much!
Post a Comment